Part 2 - Examples of a Clawback Clause for Startup Stock
Working for a startup? Learn how a clawback clause, forfeiture term or repurchase right limits the value of startup equity. Plan ahead to protect your equity stake.
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
What is a Clawback Clause?
Startup hires expect that they will be able to keep their vested shares if they leave the company before an exit event. That’s not always the case. Learn more in Part 1 of this series - Clawbacks for Startup Stock - Can I Keep What I Think I Own - about how a clawback clause limits the value of startup equity.
In this post, we will share some examples of a clawback clauses or clawback provision that would allow startups to take back vested shares or options.
What is an Example of a Clawback Clause?
Equity Incentive Plan I
The company reserves the right to include clawbacks for vested shares upon an individual's termination of employment:
Repurchase Right. The Company (and other designated Persons) may repurchase any or all of the shares of Stock granted to a Participant pursuant to an Award or acquired by the Participant pursuant to the exercise of a Stock Option upon such Participant’s termination of employment with, or Service to, the Company for any reason to the extent such a right is provided in an Award Agreement or other applicable agreement between the Company and the Participant.
Such terms could be included in any agreement with the individual, such as a Stock Option Grant Notice, a Stock Option Agreement, a Stock Option Exercise Agreement, a Termination and Release or Severance Agreement, a Restricted Stock Agreement, an RSU Agreement, an Employment or IP Agreement, or a Stockholders' Agreement.
Equity Incentive Plan II
The company reserves the right to implement a policy in the future to clawback vested or unvested shares, and you’re agreeing that such a change will apply retroactively to your shares:
Clawback Policy. The Awards granted under this Plan are subject to the terms of the Corporation’s recoupment, clawback or similar policy as it may be in effect from time to time, as well as any similar provisions of applicable law, any of which could in certain circumstances require repayment or forfeiture of Awards or any shares of Common Stock or other cash or property received with respect to the Awards (including any value received from a disposition of the shares acquired upon payment of the Awards).
Stock Option Agreement
The company reserves the right to change its bylaws in the future to clawback vested or unvested shares, and you’re agreeing that such a change will apply retroactively to your shares:
Right of Repurchase. To the extent provided in the Company’s bylaws in effect at such time the Company elects to exercise its right, the Company will have the right to repurchase all or any part of the shares of Common Stock you acquire pursuant to the exercise of your option.
These two terms allowing retroactive changes push the limits of Delaware law on company repurchase rights. However, I advise my clients to negotiate these out of their documents before joining a company to avoid litigation at a later date.
Restricted Stock Unit Grant Notice
In order to vest RSUs, the time-based vesting requirement (the "Time Condition") must be met, and the Company must have an IPO or a Change of Control (the "Performance Vesting") prior to the 7 year expiration period of the RSU. This is a normal structure for a startup RSU grant due to tax planning. However, in this example, if the IPO or Change of Control does not occur by the individual's last date of employment, the RSUs are cancelled and never vest:
Vesting Conditions. Any Restricted Stock Units that have satisfied the Time Condition as of such date shall remain subject to the Performance Vesting set forth in Section 2(b) above, but shall expire and be of no further force or effect on the first to occur of (a) the date on which the Grantee’s Service Relationship with the Company terminates, or (b) the Expiration Date.
Employment and Confidentiality Agreement
The company reserves the right to terminate vested options in the event of a breach of the agreement:
Breach of Confidentiality Agreement. If the Optionee breaches the provisions of the Confidentiality Agreement, then any outstanding Options held by such Optionee at the actual time of such termination shall thereupon expire, terminate and be cancelled in respect of all vested and unvested Option Shares.
Breach of Non-Competition and Non-Solicitation Covenant. If the Optionee breaches the Non-Competition and Non-Solicitation Agreement, then any outstanding Options held by such Optionee at the actual time of such termination shall thereupon expire, terminate and be cancelled in respect of all vested or unvested Option Shares.
While these two examples from employment and confidentiality agreements apply to restrictions on exercising options, similar terms may also apply to repurchase or forfeiture of vested shares for violations of such agreements even after termination of employment. More on this here from the National Association of Stock Plan Professionals in June 2023.
Other Clawback Clauses
These are only a few examples of how clawbacks might appear in an equity offer. There are more ways they can appear in the fine print. And, practically, an option exercise deadline acts as a clawback as well. Having only 3 months to exercise options is a standard market term, but it often acts to prevent employees and executives from exercising their vested shares. More on this in:
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
Thank you!
Thank you to JD McCullough for editing this post. He is a health tech entrepreneur, interested in connecting and improving businesses, products, and people.
Clawback Clause for Startup Stock - Can I Keep What I think I Own?
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
Updated October 19, 2020 for a recent clawback event in the news.
Everyone loves a gold rush story about startup hires making millions on startup equity. But not all startup equity is created equal. If a startup adds a repurchase rights for vested shares (a.k.a. a clawback clause or clawback provision) to its agreements, individuals may lose the value of their vested equity because a company can force them to sell their shares back to the company in certain situations, such as if they leave their jobs or are fired prior to IPO or acquisition. Other examples of a clawback clause are forfeiture (rather than repurchase) of vested shares or options at termination of employment or for violation of IP agreements or non-competes.
Image from Babak Nivi of Venture Hacks, who warns startup founders and hires to “run screaming from” startup offers with a clawback clause for vested shares: “Founders and employees should not agree to this provision under any circumstances. Read your option plan carefully.”
How a Clawback Clause Limits Startup Equity Value
In a true startup equity plan, executives and employees earn shares, which they continue to own when they leave the company. There are special rules about vesting and requirements for exercising options, but once the shares are earned (and options exercised), these stockholders have true ownership rights.
But for startups with a clawback clause, individuals earn shares they don’t really own. In the case of repurchase rights for vested shares, the company can purchase the shares upon certain events, most commonly after the individual leaves or is terminated by the company. If the individual is still at the company at the time of an IPO or acquisition, they get the full value of the shares. If not, the company can buy back the shares at a discounted price, called the “fair market value” of the common stock (“FMV”) on the date of termination of employment or other triggering event.
Most hires do not know about the clawback clause when they negotiate an offer, join a company or exercise their stock options. This means they are earning equity and purchasing shares but do not have a true sense of its value or their ownership rights (or lack thereof).
Clawback Clause “Horrible” for Employees - Sam Altman of Y Combinator
In some cases a stockholder would be happy to sell their shares back to the company. But repurchase rights are not designed with the individual’s interests in mind. They allow the company to buy the shares back against the stockholder’s will and at a discounted price per share known as the “fair market value” or “FMV” of the common stock. As Sam Altman (now CEO of OpenAI) wrote when he was the head of Y Combinator, “It’s fine if the company wants to offer to repurchase the shares, but it’s horrible for the company to be able to demand this.”
The FMV paid by the company for the shares is not the true value for two reasons. First, the true value of common stock is close to the preferred stock price per share (the price that is paid by investors for stock and which is used to define the valuation of the startup), but the buyback FMV is far lower than this valuation. Second, the real value of owning startup stock comes at the exit event - IPO or acquisition. This early buyback prevents the stockholder realizing that growth or “pop” in value.
What is an Example of a Clawback Clause?
Famous Example - Skype Shares Worth $0 in $8.5 Billion Acquisition by Microsoft
In 2011, when Microsoft bought Skype for $8.5 billion (that’s a B), some former employees and executives were outraged when they found that their equity was worth $0 because of a clawback in their equity documents. Their shock followed a period of disbelief, during which they insisted that they owned the shares. They couldn’t lose something they owned, right?
One former employee who received $0 in the acquisition said that while the fine print of the legal documents did set forth this company right, he was not aware of it when he joined. “I would have never gone to work there had I known,” he told Bloomberg. According to Bloomberg, “The only mention that the company had the right to buy if he left in less than five years came in a single sentence toward the end of the document that referred him to yet another document, which he never bothered to read.”
Both Skype and the investors who implemented the clawbacks, Silver Lake Partners, were called out in the press as “evil,” the startup community’s indignation did not change the legal status of the employees and executives who were cut out of millions of dollars of value in the deal.
Recent Example - Tanium, funded by Salesforce Ventures and Andreessen Horowitz, claws back employee shares
More recently, Business Insider reported that Tanium, funded by Salesforce Ventures and Andreessen Horowitz, has forced employees to sell their shares back to the company at FMV after their employment is terminated.
The employees interviewed by Business Insider were not aware of that their contract included this clawback when they accepted their offers. “'Surprised' was my initial reaction," one such employee said. "I had not heard of that happening before. To me it felt like a gut punch. One of the reasons for working for the company is dangling the carrot of eventually going public or eventually getting acquired so employees would monetarily benefit from that.”
How Does a Clawback Provision Work?
Hypothetical Example #1 - Company Does NOT Have Clawback Clause for Vested Shares - Share Value: $1.7 Million
Here’s an example of how an individual would earn the value of startup stock without repurchase rights or clawbacks. In the case of an early hire of Ruckus Wireless, Inc., the value would have grown as shown below.
This is an example of a hypothetical early hire of Ruckus Wireless, which went public in 2012. It assumes that the company did not restrict executive or employee equity with repurchase rights or other clawbacks for vested shares. This person would have had the right to hold the shares until IPO and earn $1.7 million.
This is an example of a hypothetical early hire of Ruckus Wireless, which went public in 2012. It assumes that the company did not restrict executive or employee equity with repurchase rights or other clawbacks for vested shares. This person would have had the right to hold the shares until IPO and earn $1.7 million. If you want to see the working calculations, see this Google Sheet.
These calculations were estimated from company public filings with the State of California, the State of Delaware, and the Securities and Exchange Commission. For more on these calculations, see The One Percent: How 1% of Ruckus Wireless at Series A Became $1.7 million at IPO.
Hypothetical Example #2 - Company Has Clawback Clause for Vested Shares - Share Value: $68,916
If the company had the right to repurchase the shares at FMV at the individual’s departure, and they left after four years of service when the shares were fully vested, the forced buyout price would have been $68,916 (estimated). This would have caused the stockholder to forfeit $1,635,054 in value.
In this hypothetical, the individual would have lost $1,635,054 in value if the shares were repurchased at their termination. If you want to see the working calculations, see this Google Sheet.
No Surprises - Identifying a Clawback Clause During Negotiation
As you can see, clawbacks dramatically affect the value of startup stock. For some clients, this term is a deal breaker when they are negotiating a startup offer. For others, it makes cash compensation more important in their negotiation. Either way, it’s essential to know about this term when evaluating and negotiating an offer, or in considering the value of equity after joining a startup.
Unfortunately this term is not likely to be spelled out in an offer letter. It can appear in any number of documents such as stock option agreements, stockholders agreements, bylaws, IP agreements or non-compete agreements. These are not usually offered to a recruit before they sign the offer letter and joining the company. But they can be requested and reviewed during the negotiation stage to discover and renegotiate clawbacks and other red-flag terms.
What is a Typical Clawback Clause?
For examples of typical clawback clause language, see Part 2 - Examples of Clawbacks for Startup Stock.
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
Early Exercise of Startup Stock Options
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
Planning for your startup stock options? Consider an early exercise of stock options to protect your equity stake from taxes and forfeiture.
Most people learn the hard way about the complexity of exercising stock options at a startup. If you can spare a few minutes of attention, this post will teach you about early exercise - the easy street of startup stock option exercise strategies.
Early Exercise Stock Options
An “early exercise” is an exercise of unvested stock options. You pay the exercise price to the company and file an 83(b) election with the IRS before the options vest.
Early exercise makes you the owner of the shares in the eyes of the company. The shares are still subject to the options’ original vesting schedule, though, as the unvested shares can be repurchased from you if you leave the company prior to your vesting milestones. The repurchase price for unvested shares is usually the lower of your exercise price or the fair market value (“FMV”) on the date of termination.
Early exercise with an 83(b) election also makes you the owner of the shares in the eyes of the IRS. That means you start your capital gains and, perhaps, Qualified Small Business Stock (“QSBS”) holding periods, which sets you up for the lowest possible tax rates when you sell your shares.
Tax Benefits of Early Exercise of Stock Options
If you early exercise while your exercise price is equal to the FMV of the common shares, the exercise itself is not taxable and therefore defers all taxation until you sell the shares and have cash gains to use to pay the taxes.
This may seem like overkill on planning, but the tax bill for a later option exercise can snowball surprisingly quickly and make it impossible to exercise vested stock options. More on this here: Startup Stock Options - Early Expiration - The $1M Problem. Early exercise can, therefore, act as a forfeiture-avoidance strategy as it can defer taxes until sale of stock and, therefore, save people from prohibitive pre-liquidity tax bills for exercise.
When to Early Exercise Stock Options
Since options are granted with an exercise price equal to the FMV on the date of grant, it’s a safe bet to early exercise immediately after grant to be sure you can do so without a tax cost.
The most common approach is to negotiate for the right to early exercise in the grant at the offer letter stage, and then join the company and wait a while before early exercising. This allows employees to get some visibility on the company’s possibility of success and their own fit within the company. So long as the early exercise is completed while the FMV is still equal to the strike price, the early exercise is tax free.
If you early exercise (or exercise vested options) after the FMV has increased above the exercise price (such as after a round of funding following your grant date) you will have taxable income on the difference between the FMV and the exercise price in the year of exercise. (The tax rates depend on whether you are early exercising NQSO or making an qualifying early exercise of ISOs.) This might seem unappealing, as you would of course prefer to defer all taxes until sale of stock. However, some people choose to early exercise even if they have to recognize income on that early exercise in order to be taxed at exercise on the current FMV rather than paying higher taxes on a later exercise based on a higher FMV.
Investment Risk of Early Exercise Options
The downside of early exercising startup stock options is investment risk, as you have to pay the exercise price (and, perhaps, some taxes at exercise) out of pocket before you have any visibility into whether the value of the shares will go up in the future. That’s why early exercise is very common and an easy choice at early stage companies where the FMV and, therefore, the exercise price is low. For instance, a first employee might be able to exercise 1% of the company for, say, $5,000. It’s a less obvious choice when the company is at a later stage and the exercise price of stock options is significant. For instance, some startup stock options packages have a $1M+ exercise price.
Some key hires of later stage startups with higher option exercise prices negotiate for the right to early exercise (or exercise vested options) with a promissory note instead of cash. Instead of paying their significant exercise price with cash, they deliver a promissory note to the company. This is a promise to pay the exercise price at some date in the future. There is some complexity to this to address with your advisor if you are considering this path.
Negotiating the Right to Early Exercise Options
Early exercise is not available at every company. Therefore, if you want to early exercise you will need to negotiate for this right during your offer letter negotiation or after you join the company.
For example, some early Uber employees negotiated to add the right to early exercise to their existing stock option grants. This allowed them to early exercise their unvested options (and exercise their vested options) before the FMV of the shares skyrocketed, so that the tax bill for the exercise was only in the tens of thousands of dollars.
Despite the out-of-pocket cost for the exercise price and taxes, this was a wise exercise choice for a few reasons. First, if they had waited and exercised after the FMV skyrocketed they would have had to pay far more in taxes to exercise - in some cases more than $1M. More on that issue here. Second, if they had failed to early exercise and ended up leaving the company prior to the company’s IPO, they would have had to come up with those astronomical tax payments before they had a market to sell the stock. This is because the company had only a 30-day post-termination exercise deadline and an absolute prohibition on sales of stock prior to IPO. Third, many of these employees purchased their shares while the company was QSBS eligible and then held the shares for the 5-year QSBS holding period. This qualified them for 0% federal tax rates on up to $10M in gains on the sale of their shares.
ISOs v. NSOs and Early Exercise Stock Options
If you are early exercising stock options, it is more favorable to have the options granted as NQSO rather than ISOs. If you early exercise ISOs, you have to hold the shares for two years before sale for long-term capital gains tax rates on your gains. If you early exercise NSOs, you only have to hold the shares for one year for capital gains treatment. Therefore, if you are planning to early exercise immediately after the grant, you will want to ask the company to make the grant as a NQSO rather than an ISO.
If you are not planning to early exercise, you may not want to include the right to early exercise in your documents. That’s because of the $100K limitation on ISOs. ISOs are a tax-favored stock option that are subject to certain limits under the tax code. Only $100K in exercise price of stock options can become exercisable in any given year and qualify as ISOs. So if you have a $400K exercise price grant that is intended to be ISOs, all $400K of the options will be ISOs if you do not include the right to early exercise. If you do include the right to early exercise, all $400K will become exercisable in the first year and so only $100K of the options will be ISOs. The remainder will be NSOs which are less tax favored.
Don’t Forget the Section 83(b) Election
If you early exercise unvested stock options, you file a Section 83(b) election with the IRS within 30 days of the exercise. The consequences of a missed 83(b) election can be very, very unappealing. If you don’t have the attention necessary to follow through on that, don’t early exercise.
When to Exercise Stock Options
As you can see, early exercise of stock options is not the best choice in every situation. To learn about the best structures for a variety of cases, see Examples of Good Startup Equity Design by Company Stage. For a comprehensive analysis of when to exercise stock options, see this three-part series:
Part 2: The Menu of Startup Stock Option Exercise Strategies
Part 3: FAQ on the Menu of Startup Stock Option Exercise Strategies
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
Silicon Valley Wins Big With Tax Break Aimed at Small Businesses: An eight-figure IPO windfall can mean a zero-digit tax bill
"If you planned well, you ended up with a phenomenal result," says Mary Russell, an attorney at Stock Option Counsel in Palo Alto, Calif., who advises tech employees on their compensation. "If you didn’t, you were in a really tight, messy spot." Photo by Mikhail Nilov.
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
Startup equity and Stock Option Counsel, P.C. in Bloomberg Business this week:
“While venture investors and founders, who can afford top-notch tax advice, are using [the Qualified Small Business Stock tax provision to take advantage of 0% tax rates on startup gains], tech workers might not be as lucky. The rules are complicated, and it can be easy to miss out. For example, early employees needed to have exercised options at a time when their startup was still under $50 million in assets. ‘If you planned well, you ended up with a phenomenal result,’ says Mary Russell, an attorney at Stock Option Counsel in Palo Alto, Calif., who advises tech employees on their compensation. ‘If you didn’t, you were in a really tight, messy spot.’”
For more information about planning for option exercises, see The Menu of Stock Option Exercise Strategies. Happy strategizing!
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
Seed Stage Startup Job Offer - Equity Negotiation Checklist
Working for a Startup? Seed Stage Startup Job Offer Equity Compensation Negotiation Checklist. Image from rawpixel.com.
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
Have a job offer from a seed stage startup? Individuals work for equity at seed stage startups (otherwise known as early stage startups) with the expectation that they will have great financial success if the company itself is successful. That dream can come true, but it depends on taking care of a few key details of the option or restricted stock at the offer negotiation stage. Here’s the Stock Option Counsel negotiation checklist for seed stage startup offer negotiations.
Percentage Ownership. The lore of Silicon Valley is that anyone who joins an early stage startup that is later a huge success will become rich. But if they fail to negotiate a significant number of shares at hire, they cannot expect that the value of their interest at the time of an acquisition or IPO will be impressive. Since being one of the first startup employees is extremely risky, there needs to be enough equity in the offer to balance that risk. I have seen individuals who are disappointed (to say the least) in these situations when they have accepted a below-market equity percentage and assumed that the founders would “take care of them” in the future. With these points in mind, I recommend taking the following steps before agreeing to join a startup:
Negotiate for enough shares up-front to balance the risk in joining the company. This is based on market norms, so do plenty of research among colleagues and advisors to confidently set market-based expectations.
Insist on time-based, not performance or milestone, vesting.
Expect that the equity interest will be significantly diluted and negotiate for enough shares to cover that expectation.
Making it Official. At the earliest stage startups, employees and founders often work for promises of future equity without signing the necessary paperwork to ensure that they have the legal right to that equity. They often start working with vague promises of future grants and “trust” that their business partners will “take care of them” in the future. This is misguided, as the purpose of a stock option grant or any written agreement is to not have to rely solely on the trust you have in any individual person. Since changes in leadership, investors, direction, etc. are guaranteed to happen at some point in time, you need protection from the company not promises from the current leaders. Before signing an Offer Letter or beginning work, I suggest to first:
Ask for a copy of the Form of Stock Option Grant or Restricted Stock Purchase Agreement, along with any other documents referenced therein. Review the terms and negotiate any issues.
Ask the company to confirm that the board will officially make the equity grant promptly after hire.
Board Approval Timing. Early stage startup companies often delay officially making grants to the detriment of their employees. This is due to administrative disorganization, a desire to delay the legal and valuation expenses of making the grant, or even a disagreement among executives and investors about how much equity should be allocated for employee grants. After starting in the role, take the following steps:
Follow up to be sure the grant is made by the board promptly. This should not take more than a couple of months.
Compare the terms of the grant to be sure they are as-agreed during the offer negotiation stage.
Tax Planning. The potential tax benefits to receiving equity in an early stage startup are unparallelled. The structure may allow for tax deferral until sale of stock - which avoids the problem of paying taxes on option exercise before liquidity - and lower capital gains tax rates or even 0% QSBS tax rates on gains. Achieving these tax benefits requires precise design by the company - such as restricted stock or early exercised stock options - and effective execution by the individual - such as the timely delivery of the purchase price and filing of the Section 83(b) election with the IRS. Early tax planning action items are:
Negotiate the tax structure during the offer negotiation stage. The right structure will depend on the stage of the company, so work with advisors if necessary to determine the most desirable structure for your grant.
Take care of the required follow-through to take advantage of the most desirable tax structures.
Legal Terms. Startup employees are sometimes very surprised by the legal terms in their grant years after they have accepted its terms. They might have assumed that they have the right to hold the shares that they have purchased and vested and find out that the company can forcibly repurchase the shares at their termination. Or they might assume that they have the right to earn their unvested shares following an acquisition but find out that they can be cancelled as part of the deal without payment. To avoid these and other unpleasant surprises regarding the legal terms of a grant, take the following steps during negotiation:
Ask for a copy of the Form of Stock Option Grant or Restricted Stock Purchase Agreement, along with any other documents referenced therein.
Review the terms and negotiate any issues before committing to joining.
If the legal terms have unexpected risks, negotiate for more shares or more cash compensation to balance the risk.
Have an offer from a seed stage startup? Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
Have an Offer Letter from a Startup? The Equity Issues are Between the Lines
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
Working for a startup? Learn more about the fine print terms of an offer letter. Plan ahead to protect your equity stake.
If you have an Offer Letter from a startup, you may notice that it’s light on information about stock options. You may see a few sentences noting that (1) the company will recommend to the board that the grant be made at the first market value on the date of grant; (2) the option will vest monthly over four years with a one-year cliff; and (3) the option will be governed by the company’s equity incentive plan and your stock option agreement. It sounds simple. But the key issues are hidden between the lines.
Change of Control Protections for Unvested Shares
A standard vesting schedule does not provide protection for unvested shares in the event the company is acquired. If you are joining in a senior position or as an early stage employee, consider negotiating for a double trigger acceleration upon change of control to protect the right to earn unvested shares. The most robust double trigger language would provide that 100% of unvested shares will accelerate if you are terminated or constructively terminated as part of or at any time following a change of control. See this blog post for more information on change of control terms for startup equity offers.
Clawbacks for Vested Shares
The equity incentive plan and stock option agreement are usually not provided with the Offer Letter unless requested, as the official equity grant is not made until after the start date. However, these agreements contain important details about the grant, so it makes sense to review them before agreeing to the number of shares or signing the Offer Letter.
For example, the equity incentive plan and stock option agreement may give the company the right to forcibly repurchase shares from the employee after termination of employment, even if they are vested shares of restricted stock or vested shares issued upon exercise of options. See this post for some examples of how those clawbacks may be drafted. Clawbacks dramatically limit the value of the equity, as the most significant increase in the value of startups has historically been at the time of an exit event. If this term, or any other red flag term, appears in the form documents, it makes sense to negotiate these out of the deal or provide for alternative compensation to make up for the potential loss in value before signing the Offer Letter.
Tax Structure
The Offer Letter may not include the terms of the tax structure, but if you have any leverage on those terms the Offer Letter negotiation is the time to address them. The right tax structure will balance your interests in total value, low tax rates, tax deferral, limited tax risks and investment deferral. This balance is different at each company stage. For example, at the earliest stage startups you may be able to meet all those goals with the purchase of Restricted Stock for a de minimis purchase price. At mid-stage startups you might prefer to have Incentive Stock Options with an extended post-termination exercise period to defer the investment until a liquidity event. At late-stage startups you might prefer Restricted Stock Units for a full value grant. See this blog post on Examples of Good Startup Equity Design by Company Stage and this blog post on The Menu of Stock Option Exercise Strategies.
Grant Timing
The company will set the exercise price at the fair market value ("FMV") on the date the board grants the options to you. This price is not negotiable, but to protect your interests you want to follow up after your start date to be sure that the board makes the grant of the options soon after your start date. If they delay granting you the options until after a financing or other important event, the FMV and the exercise price will go up. This would reduce the value of your stock options by the increase in value of the company’s common stock during that time.
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
VIDEO: Founder Restricted Stock Purchase Agreements
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
Are you a founder with a restricted stock purchase agreement (RSPA)? Protect your equity stake with change of control vesting acceleration, Section 83(b) election and fine print details.
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
VIDEO Startup Stock Options: Exercise Price Basics
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
The Good Stuff - Continuation Plans - How To Avoid the Juno Drivers' Fate of Cancelled RSUs in a $200 Million Acquisition
If you're negotiating a startup equity offer, ask for the good stuff - a Continuation Plan - or even more favorable single or double trigger acceleration terms. Photo by Erik Mclean.
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
Bloomberg reported on startup Juno's rescission of driver’s RSU awards in its $200 acquisition by Gett. They reported that Juno promised 50% of founders shares to drivers, but that it appears that the maximum portion of the acquisition price they could have received was 1.5%.
What was the disconnect? A type of startup equity plan - a Cancellation Plan - that can dramatically limit the value of employee equity grants.
Some startup stock plans allow companies to cancel unvested equity in an acquisition without payment for the shares, even if the employees holding that unvested equity stay in service after the closing of the deal. We'll call these Cancellation Plans. (You can read more on all the variations of change of control terms in startup equity offers here.)
The standard for startup stock plans has historically been that unvested employee equity must be continued or substituted in an acquisition rather than cancelled without payment. We'll call these Continuation Plans. This means they must be replaced with either cash or equity awards with the same value as the deal consideration for the shares being cancelled. If they are not replaced for the deal value, their vesting will be immediately accelerated at the acquisition and paid the entire deal price for the vested and unvested shares. The replacement still must be earned over the original vesting schedule, so there's no guarantee of earning the unvested shares without also having single or double acceleration upon change of control protections. However, this traditional requirement offered protection of value for employees. Those who stay at the acquiring company under a Continuation Plan will continue to earn the deal consideration for their shares in some other form.
The Cancellation Plans that allow cancellation of in-the-money unvested equity without payment are grabbing value from employee shares. Unvested equity - RSUs, options, etc. - can be cancelled and replaced with $0. For example, if an employee's total number of RSUs were worth $200,000 at the acquisition price, and only 50% had vested at the acquisition, the employee would be paid $100,000 and the remaining $100,000 in value of RSUs would be cancelled without payment, continuation or substitution even if the employee stays as an employee after the acquisition.
In a Continuation Plan, an employee would receive the $100,000 deal consideration for the vested shares and a substitution or continuation award in exchange for the $100,000 in unvested value. That might be in the form of cash to vest over time, continuing awards in the acquired company if it survives the merger, or substitute value of the acquiring company's equity, such as RSUs worth $100,000 in value of the acquiring company. Any such replacements would continue to vest over the original remaining vesting schedule.
When Juno, a ride-sharing app which promised 50% of its founders shares to drivers in the form of RSUs, was acquired by Gett for $200 million, they cancelled without payment all RSUs it had awarded and promised to drivers. The merger terms were not made public, but it appears that Juno had a Cancellation Plan allowing the company the right - which they exercised - to cancel unvested RSUs. All RSUs would have been unvested as the drivers reportedly had to work for 30 months to time-vest any of their RSUs and less than a year had passed between the grants and the acquisition.
The drivers instead received a one-time payment, which appears to be dramatically lower than the RSUs would have been valued in the acquisition. It was reported that the maximum portion of the acquisition price they could have received was 1.5%. It's not entirely clear that this is the case, as drivers report that they were never notified of their percentage ownership in the company at the time of the acquisition. But if the paltry payouts - one example was $250 to a driver - were actually at the deal consideration for the deal, it would mean that the original awards were such a low percentage of the company that they would have crossed into absurdity. Therefore, it safe to assume that Juno had a Cancellation Plan and it used it to cut its drivers out of a $200 million acquisition, less than a year after promising its drivers 50% of the company's equity. Ouch.
So if you're negotiating a startup equity offer, ask for the good stuff - a Continuation Plan - or even more favorable single or double trigger acceleration terms. More on those variations here.
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
Will this Seed Stage Company Become a Unicorn?
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
Wondering if your seed stage startup will become a unicorn? Here's a great illustration of your chances from Dustin Moskovitz's presentation, Why to Start a Startup from Y Combinator's Startup School.
Wondering if your seed stage startup will become a unicorn? Here's a great illustration of your chances from Dustin Moskovitz's presentation, Why to Start a Startup from Y Combinator's Startup School.
For more, see the full presentation on YouTube.
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
The C-Level View - Fine Print Issues in Startup Executive Equity Grants
Executives joining startups study the equity grant documents carefully for these issues to avoid surprises in the fine print that might limit the value of their equity. Photo by Daniel Putzer.
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
For executives trading significant cash compensation for startup equity, the fine print of the equity documents can significantly change the risk/reward profile of the deal. Be on the lookout for value-limiting terms in the Equity Grant Agreements, the Stock Plan and the Certificate of Incorporation.
Equity Grant Agreements
The Equity Grant Agreements and Stock Plan are usually not provided to the executive with the Offer Letter, as the official equity grant is not made until after hire. However, these agreements contain important details about the grant, so it makes sense to review them before agreeing to the number of shares or signing the Offer Letter.
For example, the Equity Grant Agreements may give the company the right to forcibly repurchase shares from the executive after termination of employment, even if they are vested shares of restricted stock or vested shares issued upon exercise of options. This dramatically limits the value of the equity, as the most significant increase in value of startups has historically been at the time of an exit event.
They may also require the executive to agree to future retroactive changes to the terms of the equity. For example, they may include the executive’s agreement to be bound to repurchase rights that might appear in future changes to the bylaws or the executive’s agreement to sign onto exercise agreements or stockholder agreements in the future which may have onerous terms.
If the Equity Grant Agreements have repurchase or other forfeiture rights for vested shares, it makes sense to negotiate these out of the deal or provide for alternative compensation to make up for the potential loss in value. If the Equity Grant Agreements have commitments to be bound by unknown future terms, it makes sense to remove these commitments and have all relevant terms provided up front.
The Equity Grant Agreements will outline the tax structure of the grant and the expiration period for stock options. These can dramatically improve or limit the value of the grant. A well-designed stock option tax structure can provide for Qualified Small Business Stock tax treatment, which allows for 0% federal tax rates on the first $10M in gains. A poorly-designed stock option tax structure can lead to forfeiture of vested shares or a $1M+ tax bill before liquidity to cover those taxes. The key is to understand the proposed structure and negotiate for any changes to make it consistent with the intended option exercise strategy. It might even make sense to re-design the grant as an RSU rather than a stock option.
The Stock Plan
The Stock Plan (otherwise known as an Equity Incentive Plan) can have some of the same red flags addressed above under Equity Grant Agreements. They may also have other onerous terms especially relating to treatment of executive shares in a change of control. The company may reserve the right to terminate, for no consideration, all unvested options at change of control. This could be a significant cancellation of value and could seriously decrease the executive’s leverage in negotiation of post-acquisition employment terms. Also, if an executive has negotiated for favorable double trigger vesting acceleration upon change of control rights, this term could invalidate that benefit, as cancelled unvested options would not be available for acceleration in the event of a post-acquisition termination.
If the Stock Plan has this or other onerous terms, it makes sense to negotiate for modifications in the Equity Grant Agreements or for a grant made outside the Stock Plan with terms crafted for the individual executive. If the Stock Plan has a company right to cancel unvested options at change of control, it makes sense to address this directly in the language of the executive’s vesting acceleration upon change of control term so that the cancellation cannot occur without a corresponding acceleration of vesting.
Certificate of Incorporation
The Certificate of Incorporation will outline some key economic rights of investors, including their liquidation preferences. Executives joining established startups can be misled by their percentage ownership if the investors have significant liquidation preferences, either because of significant fundraising or onerous investor terms. For example, in a company with $50 million investment and outsized investor rights of 3X participating liquidation preference, the investors would take the first $150 million in acquisition proceeds and participate with common stockholders in the distribution of the remaining proceeds.
If investor liquidation preferences are high, it makes sense for an executive to negotiate for significantly more shares to balance the risk or negotiate for a management retention bonus to be earned upon acquisition to make up for the loss in equity value due to these preferences.
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
The Not So Old Girls' Club: Women in Tech Building Their Own Professional Networks
Working with a great network can make career success much easier (and perhaps simply possible) to achieve. Without a built-in old-boys-club network, smart women in tech are thoughtfully constructing their own. Photo by olia danilevich.
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
Working with a great network can make career success much easier (and perhaps simply possible) to achieve.
When women talk about advancing their careers, they often talk about their lack of an “old boys’ club” to move them forward. In particular, women in the tech industry are uniquely aware of their need for a network. Without a built-in network, smart women in tech are thoughtfully constructing their own.
Mentors Far and Wide
The first step in building a network is recognizing that it takes a community to build a career and then committing to not go it alone. After they make this commitment, networkers find that informal mentors start to appear from far and wide to guide their paths.
According to Patricia K. Gillette, Esq., a partner in the employment law group at Orrick in San Francisco, “A mentor is someone, and I think it’s a variety of people in your life, who are going to help you navigate certain aspects of your life, whether it's your personal life, whether it's your work life, whether it's how you exercise, whether it's what you do for fun.”
Mentors are people you feel comfortable with. As Pat notes, “They're people who know you and are going to respond to you in a caring way and thoughtful way.
Diversity is important to get great perspectives. “They do not have to look like you,” Pat says. “They do not have to be the same gender or race. They don't have to be you.”
There will be many mentors in a well-connected life, but mentors are only one piece of the network necessary for advancing a career.
Sponsors within Your Organization
A sponsor is necessary in order to advance in an organization. A sponsor is someone in a very high position of leadership who advocates on one’s behalf within the organization.
A sponsor is going to “advocate for ways for you to increase your power within the organization either on the work side or on the leadership side on the economic side on the business building side,” Pat says. “You have to find a sponsor and you have to make sure you click with that sponsor and that that sponsor is willing to advocate for you. That's the way you advance within firms.”
A sponsor is completely different from a mentor. According to Pat, a sponsor is not someone to ask, “‘Where shall I stand in court? Shall I file this brief early?’ That's not what this person is.” In fact, Pat says, “a sponsor is someone who you may not like so much. A sponsor is somebody who is going to take you and say, 'The next thing you should do within the organization if you want to assume a position of power is X. And I'm going to talk to my friends within the organization to say that they ought to consider you.' That's very different from a mentor.”
What a sponsor offers is not based on altruism. To have this relationship, “you not only have to be ready, willing and able to ask, but you also have to be willing to offer something in return,” Pat says. “Usually what you offer in return is support for that person, either by being exactly as you said you were going to be - meaning you're really highly qualified and anxious and willing to accept positions of power within the organization. And also by making sure that you support that person in whatever causes he or she may have.”
See Pat’s presentation, Elimination of Bias - Women in the Law: Flying the Coop on the Wings of Economic & Institution Power, available from Lexvid: Continuing Professional Education.
Professionals
Finally, professionals provide services to help guide a career and financial path.
A great network of professionals might include:
Recruiters and hiring managers for networking and job placement
Financial planners for managing wealth, making important financial decisions, and considering career moves from a financial perspective
Attorneys for negotiation of employment contracts, stock compensation, and intellectual property matters
Accountants for tax planning and estate planning
Career and leadership coaches for individual contributors who want to move to the management level or move from there to C-level roles, or to help with participation in and running meetings, finding places to speak and be on panels or interact with senior colleagues and peers
Public speaking coach for women wishing to improve their personal brand by speaking at conferences or even presentations in the office
Negotiation coach for women wishing to advocate on their own behalf more effectively, be that when negotiating a compensation package for a new job, or for advancement in a current job and
Professionals on the person side of life, such as healthcare professionals, who in turn can improve effectiveness at work.
Opportunities for the Future
The essence of the “old boys’ club” is that their networks are built-in and are established without having to learn to create them. They meet the right contacts in their personal networks and activities. This list of network roles is meant to be a starting point for women to start to think about who is out there that would make up a community for a successful career.
As women learn the necessity of community in building a career, they may start to overcome their aversion to seeking out a network and becoming successful. Since everyone needs this, it's not wrong or overly ambitious to pursue it. As Pat notes, "[W]e see ambition as being a dirty word. There's some of us who say, 'I don't want to be ambitious, I don't want to look like I'm trying to go for everything, I don't want to look like I'm trying to get everything for myself.' That's okay, because it's not for yourself. Ultimately it's for the team, it's for your family, for your personal satisfaction."
Adding to the List
Please contact me with any suggestions of other roles that might be added to the list or descriptions of how these types of people can be helpful. I would be happy to add them to the list!
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
Quora: Formula for Option Grant Size at a Startup?
Yes, there is a formula for calculating a fair pre-IPO option grant size. Photo by Nataliya Vaitkevich.
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
QUORA QUESTION: Is there a generic formula I can apply to determine fair pre-IPO stock option grants based on the company's size and # of fully diluted shares?
I am a tech worker who has spent all of my career with post-IPO companies and am negotiating an offer with a well-established startup of approximately 250 employees. I am not taking on a senior role.
This is a simplified version of part of the process I follow with my Stock Option Counsel clients who are evaluating private company equity offers. It works best with a mid-stage startup which has had a recent funding round from a well-known VC (a.k.a. someone whose investment decision you would trust).
Recent VC Company Valuation / Fully Diluted Shares = Current "Value" per Share
Current Value per Share - Exercise Price per Option = Intrinsic Value per Option
Intrinsic Value per Option * Number of Options = Intrinsic Value of Equity Offer
Intrinsic Value of Equity Offer / Number of Years of Vesting = Annual Value of Equity Offer
Annual Value of Equity Offer + Value of Benefits + Salary + Bonus/Commission = Total Annual Compensation
Use Total Annual Compensation to evaluate the offer or compare to market opportunities.
Certain legal terms may change the risk and, therefore, the appropriate number of shares. For more on ownership limitations, see Ownership - Can the Company Take Back My Vested Shares? For more on how companies decide the right offer for startup employees, see Bull’s Eye: Negotiating the Right Job Offer.
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
Quora Post: Why Do Companies Use Equity Compensation?
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
Mary Russell: Thanks for asking me to answer this. Public companies emphasize equity because it matches pay with overall company performance. If the stockholders are doing well, employee stockholders do well.
Silicon Valley-type private companies emphasize equity because -- historically, anyway -- they were strapped for cash. They can offer employees options to purchase common stock at a discount from the price investors are paying for preferred stock. So employees receive a discount on an unusual investment in exchange for lower salaries.
But in today's marketplace for talent at these private companies, employees are negotiating for higher cash salaries than in the past. I see two reasons for this. First, private companies are having a much easier time raising cash than in years past because of the wider world of investor economics. When equity is expensive, cash becomes cheap. So these companies can and do offer higher salaries. Second, private companies are having to compete with hugely successful local public companies who are aggressively recruiting and retaining talent with impressive cash and equity offers.
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
Bull’s Eye: Negotiating the Right Job Offer
Learn the four ways startup determine the right equity offers for new hires.
Boris Epstein is the founder of BINC Search, a next-generation recruiting startup that helps Silicon Valley companies hire technical talent at the scale they need.
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
You’re negotiating your salary and equity. You know there is a right answer – a bull’s eye where the final offer should land. But where is it?
The company is deciding what to offer you. They know there is a right answer, and they’ll get there using these four factors:
1. Past Comp – your salary and equity in current and past jobs
2. Peer Comp – the salary and equity of others in your peer group within this company
3. Desired Comp – what you want to get paid, regardless of other indicators
4. Market Comp – your competitive offers in the market
The right offer for you is the bull’s eye at the center of these possible offers. You can maximize your final offer by thoughtfully using these factors in your negotiation.
Past Comp
The company may ask you to disclose your compensation in your previous positions – your Past Comp.
If you disclose these numbers, be sure to include detail or “color” on the numbers to show the true value of your Past Comp. Do you believe your salary was lower than it should have been because of difficult financial circumstance at the company? Are you overdue for a review and raise? Does your company have valuable equity or a bonus structure that should be included to accurately describe your Past Comp? Are you expecting to continue vesting or receive additional stock option grants that you would forfeit by leaving your company?
A thoughtful discussion of your Past Comp may be more effective than following the lore that you should never disclose this information. You can use your answer to the question to guide the company to the right offer.
Peer Comp
The company also considers your Peer Comp – the range this company is already paying employees in similar positions. You start shaping this number during your interview as you discuss roles, levels and opportunities and present information to help the company understand where you fit to add the most value to the team.
For a company with a thoughtful system of leveling, there will be names or labels for each position and a range of salaries and equity packages they offer within each level. Your negotiation work is to distinguish yourself and show that you are a peer of those being paid at the highest end of the range for your level based on your unique skill set or experience.
The more unique your position, the less experience a startup will have in defining your Peer Comp. If you are a first-hire designer, physician or other leadership or expert role, you may have to help the company understand who your peers will be. This is especially important in early-stage startups, where the hiring team might not understand that your new role should be considered a peer of, for example, vice presidents rather than junior engineers.
Desired Comp
The company also considers your Desired Comp – what you want to get paid. This is highly relevant to the right offer.
Desired Comp is especially important in equity packages, where your evaluation of the company’s equity may vary greatly from another candidate’s evaluation of that package. If you’ve been hoping for a home run exit during your career, you’ll be looking for an equity package that could get you there. If you’re strapped for cash and looking to maximize salary, you will have less desire for an equity-heavy final offer.
There may be some tradeoffs, of course, but the right offer will be centered on your Desired Comp. So do your self-reflection homework and know what you want.
Market Comp
Companies take into account Market Comp and need to know what they will have to offer to stay competitive. While companies have a general idea of what is “market” for each position, your personal Market Comp is unique and driven by your efforts to identify alternative offers. The only way to use the right Market Comp in your negotiation is to go out to the market, derive that information and communicate it to the company.
Once you have competitive offers, evaluate the equity packages and make thoughtful comparisons between them. For example, based on your appetite for risk and financial considerations, would you prefer options to purchase 1% of a Series A startup with a company valuation of $5 million or 5,000 RSUs of a public company with a current market price per share of $10? How many more stock options would the Series A startup have to offer you to equate to the public company offer? The company cannot make this estimation for you any more than they can decide which company is the best fit for your personality. When you own this process, you can confidently and effectively communicate to your company what is “market” for your equity offer.
Market Comp is also relevant after hire, as the startup job market can shift dramatically over time and new opportunities are always surfacing. As you continually find new information about opportunities, you can continually communicate with your company about what is “market” in defining the right salary and equity for your position.
Bull’s Eye: The Right Offer
With thoughtful attention to these four factors, you can use your negotiation to guide the company to the bull’s eye – the right offer for you. If you see the company using the wrong data, you can bring the conversation back to the truth as you see it and work toward the right outcome.
For more help on these preparations, you are welcome to read the full text of our interview here: The Right Offer – Long Form Q&A Between Stock Option Counsel and BINC Search
Boris Epstein is the founder of BINC Search, a next-generation recruiting startup that helps Silicon Valley companies hire technical talent at the scale they need.
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
Learn how startups determine the right equity stake offer for new hires.