Part 1: Why You Need a Startup Stock Option Exercise Strategy
Wondering when to exercise stock options at a startup? Here's the menu of startup stock option exercise strategies including early exercise of stock options and extended post-termination exercise periods. Plan ahead to protect your equity stake. Photo by Andrea Piacquadio.
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
When to Exercise Stock Options?
Startup stock options can be extremely lucrative or extremely disappointing. The biggest disappointments are not from companies that never succeed, but from employees of successful companies that are not able to take advanteBefore you accept a startup stock option offer, you will want to have a strategy in place for exercising those options. This up-front attention will save you from the unhappy but common surprises associated with startup stock options, such as these recent examples:
Forfeiture at Termination. Sales executive drove sales and company value for four years and was terminated a few months before a $1B company exit. He could not afford the $1M exercise cost (to cover the exercise price and tax cost of exercise) within the 30-day post-termination exercise deadline, so he was forced to forfeit most of his vested options. He made approximately $500K at the exit; his former colleagues with similar equity grants made $10M.
Golden Handcuffs. Early hire at a future unicorn did not early exercise his startup stock options or exercise as they vested. He wanted to leave the company after four years when he was fully vested, but he could not afford the $2M cost to cover the exercise price and tax cost of exercise. Therefore, he had to stay at the company for 3 more years while he waited for an acquisition, frustrated that he was not able to move onto his next opportunity.
Tax Expense. Early hire at a future public company waited to exercise his options with a total exercise price of $5,000 until after the shares became publicly traded. He had to sell the shares on the same day as the exercise to cover the tax expense of exercise. Since he had not held the shares for a year before sale, his gains were taxed at ordinary income tax rates of over 40%. If he had early exercised the options, he would have qualified for QSBS tax treatment on his gains, resulting in 0% federal tax rates and saving him >$1M in taxes.
In the Part 2, you will see the menu for startup stock option exercise strategies to save yourself from these unhappy surprises. In Part 3, you will see a Q&A on FAQs re stock option exercise strategies.
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
