Tax Changes for Startup Executives and Employees - Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 - Q1 2018 Newsletter - Stock Option Counsel, P.C.
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
Here's our Q1 2018 Newsletter. Sign up for our mailing list to receive these quarterly updates!
Hello Startup Community!
The final Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 is already affecting startup equity holders. Check out my recent blog posts on Tax-Deferred Option Exercises Under the New Section 83(i) and Incentive Stock Options & Changes to the Alternative Minimum Tax. Here's the short version.
Tax Deferral for Option Exercise - New Section 83(i) Election. The new Section 83(i) was designed to defer taxation from a stock option exercise until the shares become liquid. Unfortunately, the details of the new Section 83(i) make it unlikely to work for most startup option holders. But where it does apply it will defer taxation for up to five years from the date of option exercise with the use of the new Section 83(i) Election. These are the key details of the new Section 83(i).
Tax Relief for ISO Exercise - New AMT Limits. Dramatic increases to the exemption amounts and phase out thresholds of the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT) will allow many more startup employees to exercise Incentive Stock Options (ISOs) tax-free. This allows for more planning opportunities to take advantage of the potential ISO tax benefits of capital gains tax rates on all gains. These are the key details of the AMT changes as they relate to ISO exercise.
Startup Offer Negotiation Tips. What does this mean for our clients negotiating new stock option offers? First, the new Section 83(i) will not provide wide relief from pre-liquidity tax burdens for stock option exercise. So it still makes sense to negotiate for a tax-deferred structure such as early exercise or an extended post-termination exercise period. Second, since the revised AMT limits make the ISO benefits even more appealing than ever, ISOs are far more appealing than NSOs for most people (unless the options will be early exercised.)
Stock Option Counsel, P.C. - Legal Services for Individuals. Thank you for your enthusiasm for my practice and for the Stock Option Counsel Blog! I will continue to send quarterly updates on important topics in the market for startup equity for individual founders, executives and employees. Please keep in touch.
Best,
Mary
Mary Russell | Attorney and Founder
Stock Option Counsel, P.C. | Legal Services for Individuals
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
Tax-Deferred Option Exercises Under The New Section 83(i) - Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017
Update December 2024: I still have not seen anyone take advantage of Section 83(i). Sigh. It’s just not drafted in a way that can be helpful. Mostly I just see people confusing it with 83(b).
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.
The final Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 added a new Section 83(i) to the Code intending to allow holders of RSUs and options to defer tax on those benefits until they are able to sell the shares to cover their tax bills. Its drafting makes it unlikely to apply in practice at most startups, but where it applies it can defer taxation for up to five years from the date of option exercise or RSU vesting.
Many issues related to the Section 83(i) Election are unclear from the legislation and will need to be clarified by IRS guidance. So this is the best of my understanding as of today. This is not tax advice for readers, so please consult with your own accountant or CPA.
Update December 2024: I still have not seen anyone take advantage of Section 83(i). Sigh. It’s just not drafted in a way that can be helpful. Mostly I just see people confusing it with 83(b).
Option Exercises & Section 83(i) Election
Because well-designed startup RSUs are already structured to defer taxation until liquidity, the benefits of tax deferral under Section 83(i) are most needed for option exercises.
For eligible option exercises, a timely election under Section 83(i) will defer income at exercise until the earlier of the (i) IPO; (ii) the first date the stock becomes transferable (including to the employer), (iii) five years from exercise, (iv) the first date the employee becomes an “excluded employee,” or (v) the date the election is revoked. The 83(i) Election must be made within a 30-day period after exercise.
These are some of the eligibility requirements:
1. The company must have offered stock options on terms that provide the same rights and privileges (other than the number of shares) in the calendar year of grant to at least 80% of its U.S. employees. Since most startups do not make annual grants of stock options, this would be unlikely to apply except in years of very high growth in staff size, or to the occasional startup that gives broad-based annual refresh grants.
2. The individual must not be a significant owner or executive of the company. The ownership test is met by 1% ownership. The executive test relates to role, such as CEO and CFO, as well as total compensation, as it applies to the four most highly compensated officers of the company. Both definitions have historical applicability, such as a 10-year look back, as well as future applicability, so that if one of the definitions is met after the Section 83(i) Election, the individual becomes an “excluded employee” and the tax deferral ends.
Section 83(i) Notice
Companies are required to provide a Section 83(i) Notice to eligible employees at the time (or a reasonable period before) they become eligible to make the Section 83(i) Election. However, not all eligible employees will be aware of their eligibility, as some companies may still be in the process of assessing eligibility. Therefore, those considering option exercises at private companies may want to inquire as follows:
I understand that the new tax bill created a Section 83(i) Election to allow deferral of taxation at option exercise until the earlier of 5 years from exercise or liquidity. But there are certain rules that have to be met for an option to be eligible, including related to the company’s option grant practices, my own ownership percentage and other requirements. Can you please confirm whether, if I exercise this option, I will be eligible to make a Section 83(i) Election on the stock I purchase?
Making the Section 83(i) Election Decision
Individuals who are eligible to make the Section 83(i) Election will want to consider the pros and cons based on the tax consequences and their investment plans. For example, exercising options and filing the Section 83(i) Election will not solve the pre-liquidity taxation problem if there is not a liquidity event before the five-year (or earlier) deadline. And the Section 83(i) Election converts ISOs into NQSO, so any favorable tax treatment associated with ISOs would be lost. Since the alternative minimum tax exemptions have increased so dramatically, ISOs are more likely to be AMT-free at exercise. Such an ISO exercise may ultimately result in more favorable tax treatment than the Section 83(i) Election, if the shares are held for the full ISO holding periods. And, as in any option exercise, paying the exercise price itself is an investment risk and having a tax-deferred exercise does not make the exercise risk-free.
Negotiating New Offers
All well-negotiated startup equity offers include planning for investment timing, tax timing and tax rates. While the Section 83(i) Election is a new tool in that toolbox, it is not likely to be the most advantageous planning method for new grants. See this post for some examples of my favorite structures for equity offer negotiations.
Attorney Mary Russell counsels individuals on startup equity, including:
You are welcome to contact her at (650) 326-3412 or at info@stockoptioncounsel.com.